Tuesday, December 17, 2013

The Cadillac Tax and Its Impending Arrival

Should religious institutes be concerned already with the health insurance "Cadillac tax" that is set to take effect in 2018? The topic has been the subject of a few articles in recent months. This article from The Morning Call in Allentown, Pennsylvania, summarizes the dilemma that some employers see before them -- years before the Cadillac tax actually kicks in.

The sum of $10,200 is not a lot when you consider that the tax kicks in four years down the road, and insurance premiums will presumably and (arguably) necessarily rise between now and then. It is easy to conceive of that sum catching many employers off-guard if they do not do some analysis now. Religious institutes would be wise to take at look at the cost of the insurance they currently provide their employees (AND their members) and do some number crunching to see if the Cadillac tax could be arriving in your places of employment in four or five years...

EBSA Form 700 and the Contraceptive Mandate

Many religious institutes are reporting that they have received a notice from their insurance companies or their third party administrators asking them to indicate a choice or sign a form immediately with regard to their health care coverage. The form most often being asked about is the EBSA Form 700. Note that not every organization that claims to be religious needs to sign that form.

This request from insurers is coming now because insurance providers need to know whether they are on the hook under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) for providing contraceptives, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs for employees of your organization. As you hopefully know, the ACA requires all insurance coverage to provide "essential health benefits," which includes "women's preventive care." This is where the objectionable coverage for contraceptives, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs comes into play, which is the subject of dozens of lawsuits across the United States. We at RCRI have held two webinars on the subject this year to inform our members of what is happening with the "contraceptive mandate," as it has come to be known.

Back to the form that you may be asked to sign by your insurance company. There are two main ways that you may be exempt from having to provide these women's preventive services. First is if your plan is grandfathered. You should know if this applies to your employee plan already, and your insurance company should know, so I won't go into any detail on grandfathered plans here.

The second way to be exempt is if you qualify as a either a "religious employer" or as an "eligible organization." (Some would say this is two ways because they have different results.) The final regulations on the contraceptive mandate define a "religious employer" as "an employer that is organized and operates as a nonprofit entity and is referred to in section 6033(a)(3)(A)(i) or (iii) of the Code." Section 6033(a)(3)(A)(i) and (iii) of the Code refers to churches, their integrated auxiliaries, and conventions or associations of churches, as well as to the exclusively religious activities of any religious order. The italicized  phrases are the ones that are most likely to apply to religious orders and some of their sponsored ministries.

The religious institute itself most likely will qualify as a "religious employer." However, any of its ministries beyond those activities that are "exclusively religious" must be examined to see if they qualify as "integrated auxiliaries" of a church (in this case, the Catholic Church). A full explanation of what an integrated auxiliary is is beyond the scope of this blog post, but religious institutes should familiarize themselves with the criteria. (It is a similar analysis to the one conducted to determine whether a ministry is required to file a Form 990, and often hinges on whether the organization is "internally supported.") [Note: Donna Miller can provide more on this topic and how to conduct an analysis if you request it from her at dmiller@trcri.org.]

If your organization does not qualify as a "religious employer" and is not exempt outright from having to provide the contraceptive coverage, you may be an "eligible organization"-- that is, qualified for an "accommodation." This means that you do not have to pay premiums for the employees to be covered for contraception, sterilization and abortion-inducing drugs, but your insurance provider or third-party administrator DOES have to cover these items for your employees.

Although intended to be a solution to the outcry that the original definition religious employer was too narrow, this provision remains controversial for many employers who have religious objections. You can read a letter entitled "Unacceptable" dated February 10, 2012, signed by dozens of Catholic university personnel and multi-denominational theologians at this link. This letter summarizes the continuing objection that these individuals and organizations have over the amended contraceptive mandate final rules. A statement of similar content was also made by the USCCB this past summer, and that statement can be found here. On the other hand, despite its initial objection to the narrow definition of "religious employer" contained in the proposed rules, Catholic Health Association announced that it could "live with" the accommodation provision in the amended rules and would not challenge the mandate any further. Its statement can be found at the end of this NCR article.

So what is an "eligible organization"?
[A]n eligible organization is an organization that: (1) opposes providing coverage for some or all of the contraceptive services required to be covered [...] on account of religious objections; (2) is organized and operates as a nonprofit entity; (3) holds itself out as a religious organization; and (4) self-certifies that it satisfies the first three criteria (as discussed in more detail later in this section). (https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2013/07/02/2013-15866/coverage-of-certain-preventive-services-under-the-affordable-care-act#h-13)
So, in order to be an eligible organization, your organization must oppose the coverage requirements due to religious objections, be a nonprofit, hold yourself out as a religious organization, and sign certification to that effect. Notice that this is the only one of the two provisions (religious employer and eligible organization) that requires a certification to be signed. However, it is quite understandable that insurers and third-party administrators would request that religious employers also sign a form indicating their status so that they can justify not providing coverage for the objectionable women's services.

In Summary, the EBSA Form 700 is to be signed by organizations that qualify as an "eligible organization" (eligible for an accommodation). Religious employers should not sign the same form because it indicates that an accommodation should be made for the employees, and no such accommodation is required under the contraceptive mandate. An adapted Form 700 can be drafted using language that expresses that a complete exemption from the contraceptive mandate, rather than an accommodation, is being claimed.

Thursday, November 21, 2013

Do You Have a Choice in Health Insurance?

A number of religious institute members have expressed concern and disappointment in recent months over the way that the Affordable Care Act has structured health insurance on the exchanges. Because those members who work within the institute or for another Catholic employer have no reportable income, the only option available to them when they go to the state marketplace is Medicaid. Even if they wanted to pay something toward their health care, they are not allowed to apply for a non-Medicaid plan on the exchange and qualify for a subsidy.

An article yesterday by Nicole Hopkins in the Wall Street Journal expressed similar dismay over this dilemma. Hopkins' mother is age 52 and has minimal income due to circumstances in recent years. However, despite her low income, for years she has chosen to pay for her own health insurance. Under the new law, however, the policy she has been happy to pay for for years will no longer be available. Indeed, her cost would increase by 50%, and her deductible would skyrocket, if she chose to continue to pay for her own insurance. Hopkins writes:
The Sept. 26 letter from my mother's insurer promised that the more expensive plan "conforms with the new health care law"—by covering maternity needs, newborn wellness and pediatric dental care. My mother asked: "Do I need maternity care at 52?" In addition to requiring her to pay an extra $1,677 annually, the plan would have increased her deductible by $1,500.
Thinking that her mother had made a mistake and that she must be able to bypass Medicaid and opt to pay something for her coverage, Hopkins walked her mother (in the state of Washington) through the online application process from across the country (in New York). Of the application process she writes:
The situation sounded absurd, so I asked her to walk me through her application on Washington Healthplanfinder to make sure she wasn't missing anything. Sitting in New York with my computer, I logged onto the site under her name and entered the information my mother provided over the phone. I fully expected her to realize that she had forgotten some crucial piece of information, like a decimal point in her annual income. We checked and double-checked the information, but the only option still appeared to be Medicaid. She suggested clicking on "Apply for Coverage," thinking that other options might appear.
Instead, almost mockingly, her "Eligibility Results" came back: "Congratulations, we received and reviewed your application and determined [you] will receive the health care coverage listed below: Washington Apple Health. You will receive a letter telling you which managed care plan you are enrolled with." Washington Apple Health is the mawkish rebranding of Medicaid in Washington state.
The page lacked a cancel button or any way to opt out of Medicaid. It was done; she was enrolled, and there was nothing to do but click "Next" and then to sign out.
Hopkins listened as her mother explained to her why she was so averse to being forced to go on Medicaid.
"I just don't expect anything positive out of getting free health care," she said. "I don't see why other people should have to pay for my care, whether it be through taxes or otherwise." In paying for health insurance herself—she won't accept help from her family, either—she was safeguarding her dignity and independence and her sense of being a fully functioning member of society.
Before ObamaCare, Medicaid was one option. Not the option. Before this, she had never been, in effect, ordered to take a handout. Now she has been forced to join the government-reliant poor, though she would prefer to contribute her two mites. The authorities behind "affordable care" had erased her right to calculate what she was willing to spend to preserve her dignity—to determine what she thinks is affordable.
That little contribution can mean the difference between dignity and despair.
For the truly poor, being institutionally forced to take welfare is demoralizing. The Affordable Care Act is at risk of systematizing learned helplessness by telling individuals like my mother that they cannot afford to care for themselves in the way they could before the law was enacted. "This makes me feel poorer than ever," she said.
Naturally not everyone feels the same way as Hopkins' mother. Many see Medicaid as an "entitlement" that is available to anyone who qualifies. It has been, and continues to be, for many a life-saving program. And that is a good thing.

But when someone is willing and able to pay something toward her upkeep, when it matters to her that she maintain some modicum of internal pride and dignity, being forced to depend on the government is a humiliating experience. Ms. Hopkins' mother's dilemma is indeed sad.

In a country that has grown and thrived for centuries due to an indefatigable belief in hard work, unfettered  human ingenuity, and  indomitable courage, are we indeed facing a government that can tell us "we know what's best for you" (comprehensive coverage that you do not need) and "you must settle for what we give you" (Medicaid)? Sadly, it is looking that way more and more.

To read Ms. Hopkins' entire article, go to http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303531204579207724152219590.

Thursday, October 31, 2013

Various Tax Benefit Changes for 2014

The following year-end tax information is taken from IRS Newswire IR-2013-87. We have highlighted several points that affect either or both religious with earned income and/or their employees or which are commonly asked about by our members.

Note that the combined standard deduction ($6200) and personal exemption ($3950) for 2014 equals $10,150, which is the threshold amount of income that a religious (under age 65) would have to report in order to be required to file an income tax return in 2015. This could be important when it comes to determining whether a member will be susceptible to paying a tax/penalty if s/he is not covered by a qualified health insurance coverage in accord with the ACA.

Note that Revenue Procedure 2013-35 listing these and other changes is available at http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-13-35.pdf.


In 2014, Various Tax Benefits Increase
Due to Inflation Adjustments

WASHINGTON — For tax year 2014, the Internal Revenue Service announced today annual inflation adjustments for more than 40 tax provisions, including the tax rate schedules, and other tax changes. Revenue Procedure 2013-35 provides details about these annual adjustments.
The tax items for tax year 2014 of greatest interest to most taxpayers include the following dollar amounts.
  • The tax rate of 39.6 percent affects singles whose income exceeds $406,750 ($457,600 for married taxpayers filing a joint return), up from $400,000 and $450,000, respectively. The other marginal rates – 10, 15, 25, 28, 33 and 35 percent – and the related income tax thresholds are described in the revenue procedure.
  • The standard deduction rises to $6,200 for singles and married persons filing separate returns and $12,400 for married couples filing jointly, up from $6,100 and $12,200, respectively, for tax year 2013. The standard deduction for heads of household rises to $9,100, up from $8,950.
  • The limitation for itemized deductions claimed on tax year 2014 returns of individuals begins with incomes of $254,200 or more ($305,050 for married couples filing jointly).
  • The personal exemption rises to $3,950, up from the 2013 exemption of $3,900. However, the exemption is subject to a phase-out that begins with adjusted gross incomes of $254,200 ($305,050 for married couples filing jointly). It phases out completely at $376,700 ($427,550 for married couples filing jointly.)
  • The Alternative Minimum Tax exemption amount for tax year 2014 is $52,800 ($82,100, for married couples filing jointly). The 2013 exemption amount was $51,900 ($80,800 for married couples filing jointly).
  • The maximum Earned Income Credit amount is $6,143 for taxpayers filing jointly who have 3 or more qualifying children, up from a total of $6,044 for tax year 2013. The revenue procedure has a table providing maximum credit amounts for other categories, income thresholds and phaseouts.
  • Estates of decedents who die during 2014 have a basic exclusion amount of $5,340,000, up from a total of $5,250,000 for estates of decedents who died in 2013.
  • The annual exclusion for gifts remains at $14,000 for 2014.
  • The annual dollar limit on employee contributions to employer-sponsored healthcare flexible spending arrangements (FSA) remains unchanged at $2,500.
  • The foreign earned income exclusion rises to $99,200 for tax year 2014, up from $97,600, for 2013.
  • The small employer health insurance credit [SBHCTC] provides that the maximum credit is phased out based on the employer’s number of full-time equivalent employees in excess of 10 and the employer’s average annual wages in excess of $25,400 for tax year 2014, up from $25,000 for 2013.
Details on these inflation adjustments and others not listed in this release can be found in Revenue Procedure 2013-35, which will be published in Internal Revenue Bulletin 2013-47 on Nov. 18, 2013.

Confusion Surrounds Implementation of ACA

If you are finding yourself confused over what lies ahead as we quickly approach deadlines in the implementation of the Affordable Care Act, you are not alone. The employer mandate has been delayed for a year, but not the individual mandate. People all over the country are expressing mixed emotion and mixed levels of understanding about what to expect.

Recently at our National Conference in Anaheim we had two experts speak at our pre-Conference workshop on the ACA. Many religious institutes remain concerned over the requirement that essentially all health insurance policies (for men and for women alike) cover women's preventive services that include contraceptives, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs. We have a webinar scheduled for mid-November that will address in part the latest on the status of the contraceptive mandate and the ongoing litigation in courts across the United States. Watch for emails and check our website in the next few weeks when we open the webinar for registrations.

Employer Reporting of Employee Health Insurance Costs on W-2s

We continue to receive questions about the status of the ACA provision requiring employers to report on their employees' W-2s the amount that is paid for the employees' health coverage. This provision is still unsettled, and the IRS has instructed that until further notice certain employers with under 250 employees are not required to report the health coverage costs on employee W-2s. Employers can do so, but it is optional.

For more on this IRS statement, go to http://www.irs.gov/uac/Employer-Provided-Health-Coverage-Informational-Reporting-Requirements:-Questions-and-Answers.

For details on what must be reported, see the chart at this link: http://www.irs.gov/uac/Form-W-2-Reporting-of-Employer-Sponsored-Health-Coverage.

Friday, September 13, 2013

Are You Eligible for the Combined Federal Campaign?



The 2013 Combined Federal Campaign (CFC) has been launched and federal organizations across the country are preparing to participate. CFC is the largest and most successful workplace fundraising campaign in the world. It raised $7 billion for thousands of charities over the past 50 years.  In 2012, 130,000 generous federal employees gave nearly $62 million to help neighbors in need around the corner, across the nation and throughout the world.

Through the CFC’s local campaigns, federal employees have the opportunity to donate to thousands of approved charities (see for example, the complete online list of participating charities in the Washington, DC area campaign: 2013 Catalog of Caring).

The theme of this year’s campaign is “Make It Possible,” designating all the ways the CFC campaign makes it possible for federal employees to make the world a better place.  Many federal agencies will be kicking off their campaigns on October 1 and will run them until December 15 to allow employees to choose charities to receive their donations.

Although it is too late to get onto the list for 2013’s campaign (for money that will be distributed in 2014), Catholic organizations may want to apply to be on the list of eligible organizations in late 2014 (for distributions made in 2015).

RCRI produced a webinar on the CFC in 2012. You can view the webinar and learn more about this potential for fundraising at this link: http://www.trcri.org/members/CFC.php.